Skip to main content

Power BI

Needs Votes

Direct Query Semantic model

Vote (171) Share
Power BI User's profile image

Power BI User on 09 Jul 2015 12:35:38

Azure SQL and Azure DW Direct Query datasources are great, and this is most probably the future. There is however a requirement for a real-time semantic model in the middle. For example, this will be great for: captions/translations, attribute order by, hierarchies, images, relationships defined outside of the db, ... And most importantly that could provide a multidimensional query language (MDX and/or DAX). It could be Tabular in Azure or it could an in-database semantic model like SAP HANA?

Comments (20)
Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

f100ff50 d76f-44be-ba40-759bacea797d on 05 Jul 2020 22:26:01

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

This would provide my organisation with massive benefits and could be a positive reason for us to advocate selecting Power BI over another reporting tool like Tableaux.

Please provide support for Dashboards and reports using Direct Queries with calculated columns and translations.

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

7fa95d58 0661-4e6d-9c60-81834e43eecb on 05 Jul 2020 22:25:54

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

If we add a custom column in direct query mode, it says it is not supported in DirectQuery but it is needed.

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

3ece3be6 7209-4f91-8ce4-6ac66d3dd67d on 05 Jul 2020 22:25:39

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

DIffinately needed....

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

3fe3305b e258-4f4b-873e-bd67315c8b87 on 05 Jul 2020 22:25:05

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

From a data governance point of view we can only use DQ to prevent upload of confidential data the the cloud (however secure it may be). We have chosen Power BI for its self service capabilities but this gap renders that redundant. Calculations and modelling will have to be done on the SQL server by Devs, not power users in the business as was our intention. please please add the ability to create power query semantic layer with direct connect!

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

da8e5f34 1307-44e9-95b8-e62f834b77c3 on 05 Jul 2020 22:25:02

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

Direct query and Import queries must co-exist

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

d9791df6 36a0-4b3d-b059-2e32c5c99ba3 on 05 Jul 2020 22:24:57

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

Direct Query and Import queries must be able to co-exist

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

2a46fbf0 3807-4fde-93d1-d6911c0d1032 on 05 Jul 2020 22:22:02

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

This is a big limiting factor. I'm really trying to use PBI, but issues like this keep pushing me back to Tableau.

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

f9b3701f 2eea-4641-8d6c-076e1aa4b8ef on 05 Jul 2020 22:18:18

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

I have to import millions and thousands of rows just so I can compute a Year from a date field..... Not ideal

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

8a96940e dcdb-48e2-97c6-f454a6d5a9aa on 05 Jul 2020 22:12:46

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

Any progess with the DQSM as whenever i try to enhance the datamodel we are asked to use 'upoad' mode and not DC.

Power BI User's profile image Profile Picture

f1ab0820 263c-e811-a959-000d3a1be90a on 05 Jul 2020 22:10:23

RE: Direct Query Semantic model

When dealing with large data sets this is a huge requirement.